Make Your Own Gift Certificates or Hire a Gift Card Services Company?
Posted by Michael Hartzell
'Tis
the season to think about the holiday gift card options. Will you make
your own gift certificates or will you hire a gift card services
company? John Harris from Lynch + Harris offers certificate and gift
card ideas and options. If you need more assistance with certificates
or gift cards, contact John S. Harris at: ircharris@gmail.com
The Gift - Savvy Merchant
A Must for Independent Retailers, Restaurateurs & Service
Establishments
By John S. Harris
It’s Thanksgiving Week and holiday decorations, seasonal
recipes, holiday sales and special promotions start to scream at all of us. The
charge is underway, and a big chunk of the action every holiday season is that
special currency known as gift certificates, or gift cards. How does the
independent merchant compete with the chains to make the most of the
opportunity?
The answer for the independent is the same as it’s always
been. Focus on your customer base.
This is a strong suit for independents, many of whom tend to personally know or
at least recognize their best customers. These are your most loyal, most
frequent, most spending, or some combination therein. These folks also
represent your referral marketing network. The holiday season is the perfect
time to engage and reward them. Though it helps greatly to utilize an online
gift certificate service, it’s not essential. What is essential is to re-think your gift certificate or gift card
strategy to do two things: reward your fan base; and reward the potential new fans
they bring into your orbit.
Gift Certificates and Gift Cards have obvious and well known
advantages, foremost amongst them being cash in the bank well before the sale
that ultimately credits against it. But their less hyped advantages lie in
their inherent viral marketing properties. Gifts are all about giving, of
course, and there’s always a Buyer, and a Recipient involved – two consumers,
not one.
Turning one consumer into two consumers is the very
definition of viral marketing. Therefore, every single sale of a gift
certificate is an outstanding shot at a viral marketing win.
So here are some suggestions for making the most of your
gift certificate or gift card opportunities.
Issuance and
Redemption Basics: Get the nuts and bolts in place for the rush. You
cannot afford to make it difficult or time-consuming for consumers to either
buy, or redeem, gift currencies from your business. If you’ve already got a
system in place, then good for you. If not, I’ve put together a table (inset,
below) that lays out the basics of the commercial gift world – the tools
accessible to you to work the gift business.
- Treat
Gift Buyers and Redeemers THE BEST. Sure, you and your staff treat
everyone well, but the folks buying and redeeming are the best existing,
and potentially best new, customers. Viral!
- Make
Them Available Online. It’s a must that customers can buy them 24X7 and
frankly, it’s a pretty basic courtesy. Widespread, cheap and easy; see the
table of online gift certificate services (below), if you’re not already
there.
- Stock
Up. A one-dollar gift card can be sold for easily one hundred times that
amount, or more. Not a time to get caught short on either your paper or
mag-stripe gift stock.
- Train
The Troops. You and your staff must be fluent in the sale, and redemption
cycle, particularly the POS part of it. It costs nothing to set up some
practice sessions.
- Review
Your Denominations. Maybe you’ve been selling $10 certificates or cards
for years, but your average check is $16. Does that make sense?
- Know
the Law. Every state is different, but there’s been a flurry of both state
and federal legislation in the past two years. Go to www.consumersunion.org, for a
great summary..
Marketing Basics:
It is crucial to let your customers and employees know about your gift
offerings. Some inexpensive (or free), direct marketing programs that you can
make happen in a couple of days:
- Eye-catching
Signs or Posters:
- “Gift
Certificates Available – On-Line or In-Store at…”
- Table or
Counter Displays. Same message
- Staff
Buttons. Fast and cheap, a million places online can create them for you overnight
- Flyers:
- Start
putting a simple flyer into every bag or box; in every check-presenter,
etc.
- Add to
Voice Mail message:
- “Our
gift certificates are available 24X7 online…”; or “We’re open special
hours this year to provide gift certificates…”
- Add
simple text at the bottom of your receipts or invoices.
- Staff
Training. It’s easy to simply mention that you offer gift certificates or
gift cards.
Promotion Plan:
Work the gift business both online (see
table of online gift certificate services, below) and offline. Some proven
strategies include:
- Give Free
Gift Certificates to your best customers. Send them via mail or email, an
actual Gift Certificate / Card with a personal message, e.g.,”Thanks for
you business over the years.” Make sure you do it in a way that makes it
very easy for the recipient to re-gift it if they want. Most recipients
will spend more on the back-end, both in purchases and in referral
business. If you’re too busy, some companies will do a special run of Gift
Certificates complete with personalized messaging and complete fulfillment
for a very small fee.
- Buy a
Gift Certificate / Get a Gift Certificate. This promotion rewards the
purchaser with an additional, or separate, gift of their own. This is
particularly effective with office administrators, because when the
purchaser buys a $50 gift card/certificate, they would typically receive a
$10 one for themselves. The big chains do very well with this strategy –
Smith & Wollensky’s is one of many examples of what a proven technique
it is. Online gift certificate systems (see table below) are particularly adept at
automating this and capturing all the buyer and recipient info.
- Presuming
you already have some form of customer list or database, this is the
season to think more professionally about how it needs to be happening all
year long. You do not want to win new customers without capturing some
basic contact info about them! Get your website up to speed on this. Ask
whoever handles your website to add a simple online form for customers to
join your mailing list – it’s trivial and very inexpensive.
- Send a
follow-up “Thank You” via email or personal note to recipient and giver
after redemption. If the recipient is a first time customer, thank them
for coming to your store and reinforce your goal of personal service and
product selection. Also, send a ‘Thank You” to the buyer for introducing a
new customer to you and sending a best customer back to you. This simple
courtesy is worth its’ weight in gold.
Gift Systems.
It’s a brave new world out there as far as online gift certificate services are
concerned. Your most successful competitors are already there. If you’re not,
it’s never too late. Most of the systems today can be up and running in
literally one or two days. I put this table together to try and simplify a
pretty complicated industry. There are billion-dollar vendors and tiny
start-ups in this space, and hundreds of companies. So this is merely my
attempt to clarify what’s out there.
The Landscape of Online Gift Certificate Services Available
to Small Businesses
|
|
Traditional
Certificates
|
Magstripe
Cards
|
“Virtual”
Certificates
|
|
Medium
|
Paper
or Card Stock
|
Plastic
|
Email,
or Mobile Token
|
|
Easy
to sell in-store
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Not
Yet
|
|
Easy
to sell online
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
|
Time
to get up & running
|
1 -2
days
|
1 –
3 weeks
|
Varies
|
|
POS
integration
|
No
|
Yes
|
Varies
|
|
Security
level
|
Low
|
High
|
Medium
|
|
Setup
Costs
|
Low
|
High
|
Medium
|
|
Loyalty-use
option
|
No
|
Yes
|
Varies
|
|
Monthly
Fees
|
Offline=No
Online=Yes
|
Offline=Yes
Online=Yes
|
Online=Varies
|
|
Transaction
Fees
|
Offline=No
Online=Varies
|
Offline=Yes
Online=Yes
|
Online=Yes
|
|
Pros
|
Very
low cost, can now be easily put online, little to no transaction costs, very
easy to implement, many consumers like the physicality, usually specific to
one merchant
|
Medium
cost with any volume, very secure, real-time, can integrate to POS, can be
used as Loyalty card, convenient, quality format
|
Instant
delivery, more consumer personalization options, is a true “green”
alternative, a very popular option with consumers, mobile option is exciting
|
|
Cons
|
Not
as secure, not integrated with POS, printing and fulfilling is no fun, still
need quality design work, no online redemption
|
Getting
set up is typically hundreds of dollars, and POS integration adds both
initial and ongoing costs
|
Email
isn’t a very elegant gift format, redemption integration not a picnic, adds
transaction costs
|
|
Sample Vendors (with URL)
|
|
PLEASE NOTE:
This is by no means intended to be a
definitive list. There are many vendors in some of these categories and you
should search on your own for all options. Listing a company here is not an
endorsement, and no representation is made as to performance or reliability.
|
GiftLinx.com puts links on the merchant’s website and handles the actual online ordering,
printing and mailing to the merchant’s clients, a labor-saver
|
FirstData.com
has a deep, regulated list of quality magstripe system and services resellers
|
GiftTango.com
provides both Email and Mobile forms of
their virtual gift certificates. They can be customized for any merchant.
|
|
GiftCertsOnline.com also puts a link on the merchant’s website, and provides
the online ordering engine and an option to print certificates online, but
does not do fulfillment.
|
Swipeit.com
serves the small business market directly, covers setup, system and fulfillment
|
GiftCertificates.com has long enabled its certificates to be provided in email
form, with many discounting options
|
|
TheGiftCardCafe.com puts a link on the merchant’s website and handles the
online ordering. They do not do fulfillment, but offer an “Instant” eGift via
email
|
ProfitPointInc.com provides a wide array of gift, loyalty, credit and
related card marketing and operations services
|
Cashstar.com
offers virtual gift certificates in Email form, with many customization
features for consumers. Online or in-store Redemption.
|
About The Author
- John S. Harris has been a small business consultant for over
twenty years. A former owner and operator himself, John is a principal in
Lynch + Harris, a consulting firm specializing in operations management and
marketing communications that helps independent restaurants and retailers
expand their business and improve their operations. John can be reached at ircharris@gmail.com
Was this interesting or helpful? Would you consider sharing it?

Was this interesting or helpful? Would you consider sharing it?